Skip links

PETROLEUM, ENERGY, AND NIGERIA’S ECONOMY: CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES

PETROLEUM, ENERGY, AND NIGERIA’S ECONOMY: CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES

By Omowunmi Iledare, Ph.D., Snr. Fellow USAEE, Fellow NAEE, Fellow EI, Fellow NIPetE, Professor Emeritus in Petroleum Economics and Executive Director, Emmanuel Egbogah Foundation, Abuja, NG

Preamble

The connection between petroleum, energy, and the economy in Nigeria has been evident since the 1970s. Economic rent from petroleum has significantly altered the country’s structure, influencing the 1999 constitution towards rent-seeking and prebendalism. This has heightened society’s expectations regarding entitlements, resulting in increased economic populism. Consequently, there’s a public perception that petroleum resources automatically ensure affordable, sustainable energy and economic development, promising a higher quality of life. The discovery of petroleum resources is only part of the energy solution; conversion processes are crucial to addressing ongoing secondary energy challenges. Additionally, domestic energy production for export lacks the multiplier effects of domestic conversion and consumption. Consequently, affordable secondary energy sources like electricity, cooking gas, motor fuels, and jet fuels play a significant role in reducing high inflation, unemployment, and low economic growth.

As global energy systems transition from reliance on fossil fuels, Nigeria finds itself at a critical point. An understanding of the importance of good governance, transparency, and accountability in the energy sector, particularly within the petroleum value chain, is essential to maximize social and economic benefits for Nigeria. This article aims to review relevant issues from 2023 and derive conclusions to aid resolutions. Topics and implications affecting the petroleum, energy, and economy nexus in Nigeria include, but are not limited to petroleum assets divestment, oil and gas sector governance, presidential executive orders, Dangote refinery and wholesale market conduct, the evolving energy landscape, global oil and gas dominance, and navigating the energy transition trilemma.

Petroleum Asset Divestment by International Oil Companies (IOCs)

Divestments are strategic decisions, often for restructuring to maximize stakeholder value. They can also be forced by regulations or bankruptcy. Many overlook the risks and uncertainties in Nigeria’s oil and gas divestment processes. People outside the petroleum sector often do not understand the market complexities driving investments in petroleum resource development.

Divesting from less profitable assets and reorganizing portfolios is a global best practice in the oil and gas industry to maximize corporate value. Shell, Mobil, Agip, and Total’s recent divestment decisions are strategic business moves beneficial for Nigeria, enhancing government revenue access. Shell’s identification of Renaissance Consortium as a buyer and their willingness to facilitate the funding process demonstrates pragmatism. Finding suitable buyers is crucial to ensure minimal opportunity cost and balance the value received from divested assets.

Government access to revenue from these assets must remain intact, and their operation should minimize environmental hazards. The Conglomerates approved by the Nigerian government have the necessary skills to manage these assets. Their technical, managerial, and financial competence is unquestionable. Lessons from US asset divestments suggest that selling these assets to local investors could greatly benefit Nigeria’s economy and energy security. This potential is already evident in the contributions of indigenous players in Nigeria’s oil and gas industry.

It is challenging for individuals to fully grasp the difficulty of attracting international companies to compete in developing petroleum assets within the onshore continental USA, even when adequately informed. Typically, assets in mature US basins are offered for sale to independent companies with lower overheads and less ambitious earnings expectations that align with their risked-investment profiles.

Nevertheless, there are legitimate concerns and apprehensions regarding these transactions. Firstly, there is a desire for NNPCL to reduce its majority share in these JV assets to a minority ownership, following the NLNG Model. Fortunately, with the Federal Government’s approval and the endorsement of the National Economic Council, NNPC Limited can sell shares held by the Government. Given the Government’s financial needs, selling its share in NNPCL is preferable to borrowing at high capital costs and sacrificing future earnings, in my opinion. NNPC Limited continues to navigate challenges related to its inflated workforce and above-industry-average technical costs per barrel, which complicates retaining majority shares in these JV assets. Despite the reputable pedigrees of the conglomerates acquiring these divested assets, managing NNPC Limited’s inefficiencies to ensure optimal asset development may pose significant challenges.

Secondly, government access to petroleum revenue from divested IOC assets may diminish due to PIA fiscal terms onshore and shallow water assets. The royalty schemes and hydrocarbon resource tax in the PIA 2021 could limit capacity expansion and reduce revenue. Amending Schedule Seven and royalty regulations might enhance profitability for onshore and shallow assets.

Finally, future petroleum operations need proper engagement with host communities. The PIA 2021 allocates 75% of funds for capital projects, 20% for reserve funds, and 5% for administrative expenses. Communities must protect infrastructure and avoid disruptions or risk losing funds for repairs. Although controversial, this provision is rational.

Presidential Executive Order 2024 on Non-Associated  Gas

The Presidential Executive Order (PEO) 2024, intended to incentivize non-associated gas (NAG) Greenfield Development, has been widely praised by industry stakeholders and energy analysts. Oil and gas companies operating in Nigeria’s shallow-water and onshore terrains have expressed significant approval at the swift enactment of the NAG order. The aim of PEO 2024 is to enhance the competitiveness and attractiveness of investments in NAG projects.

Nigeria has previously implemented commendable measures to promote gas development within a framework of investment attractiveness and competitiveness. However, there is limited empirical evidence indicating that such incentives have substantially contributed to the national economy in terms of overall goods and services production. Notable past incentives include NLNG fiscal incentives, the Associated Gas Flaring Act incentives, Gas-to-Liquid incentives, and various incentives under the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) targeted at natural gas development.

Despite multiple incentives aimed at promoting gas development over the past several decades, the contribution of gas to the federation account remains less than optimal. Consequently, this op-ed seeks to underscore the importance of general fiscal rules in the implementation of PEO 2024 to enhance NAG development while managing intergenerational implications effectively. The principle is that incentivizing the production or development of gas without aligning the interests of all stakeholders will likely result in suboptimal outcomes. Therefore, the strategy for implementing PEO 2024 must transcend rent-seeking and rent-sharing approaches, focusing instead on maximizing the social well-being of citizens within the Federation, without compromising fiscal attractiveness and competitiveness.

Fiscal rules are essential in petroleum resource development. Expanding non-associated gas should consider intergenerational impacts, not just investment appeal and competitiveness. Understanding the interests of stakeholders—investors, government, and society—is crucial for managing economic rent from petroleum. Nigeria has made efforts to boost gas development through investment incentives, but empirical evidence showing its contribution to the national economy is limited. While public support for PEO 2024 is notable, targeting NAG with this order instead of amending PIA 2021 may be ill-advised given the current state of the Federation’s economy.

The Evolving Global Energy Landscape and its Impact on Oil and Gas in Nigeria

The shift from fossil fuels to zero-carbon sources is a major global debate, focusing on energy equity, security, and sustainability—the so-called energy trilemma. Rapid transition with a fixed date raises concerns, particularly in developing economies like Nigeria, rich in petroleum resources. The EIA projects fossil fuels will drop from 90% to 50% of the global energy supply by 2050 to meet the 2-degree Celsius global warming target.

Though there’s strong commitment to this transition, the implications of a uniform rapid switch are troubling. Potential disruptions in global economies, increased energy poverty, and heightened energy challenges, especially for emerging petroleum economies, are likely. Nigeria, with its thirty-seven billion barrels of liquid petroleum (equivalent to fifty years at the current extraction rate), depends heavily on petroleum for economic growth and social wellbeing. Furthermore, Nigeria has abundant natural gas, initially deemed not green enough.

Nigeria ranks among the top ten nations with an estimated 209 trillion cubic feet of proved natural gas reserves. Experts have opined that Nigeria is predominantly a natural gas province, with only pockets of liquid petroleum fields. Additionally, revenues from the development of petroleum resources, estimated at US$130 to US$170 billion annually, are at risk due to the rapid transition to renewable energy. This transition jeopardizes the funding necessary to develop infrastructure, promote economic growth, mitigate energy poverty, and reduce youth unemployment.

Ironically, Nigeria experiences significantly low energy access and high energy costs. With low oil and gas production, the country may face reduced productivity and international trade competitiveness amid this rapid transition. Nonetheless, oil and gas production and export remain critical to Nigeria’s economy, serving as the cornerstone of its industrial strategy. The delay in formulating a new petroleum policy framework has led to decreased major upstream investments, exceptionally low exploration and production activities, and minimal additions to reserves, putting the future of petroleum development at risk. Furthermore, the evolving energy landscape towards green energy influenced the final provisions of the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) to balance fiscal attractiveness and competitiveness across all terrains in Nigeria.

Notably, the PIA 2021 provisions on institutions and governance aim to address the persistent challenges facing Nigeria’s petroleum industry. These provisions strive to create and strengthen institutions that support industry governance through transparency, accountability, and value delivery. The principles of clear separation of roles focus on transparency and good governance across the entire value chain. This is the primary focus of the governance and institutional provisions in the PIA 2021.

The separation of roles goal relies on the governance and institutional framework driven by the Office of the Minister, two regulatory institutions (the Commission for the upstream sector and the Authority for the downstream sector), and one commercial entity. These three PIA institutions are essential in managing Nigeria’s oil and gas industry as the global energy landscape changes. The creation of a single commercial entity set up and limited by shares under the Companies and Allied Matters Act is one of the four key objectives of the PIA 2021. The PIA includes provisions to foster sustainable development and peaceful coexistence in host communities, aiming to reduce operational disruptions.

Nigeria has reformed its petroleum fiscal system to attract investors and create stability in the oil and gas sector. The Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) 2021 aims to follow global best practices and is designed to be investor friendly. Shell’s $5 billion investment and approvals granted for local consortia to buy divested assets indicate the effectiveness of PIA’s fiscal incentives.

The PIA’s fiscal framework for natural gas development prioritizes using natural gas to drive the national economy rather than optimizing revenue extraction. This decision supports the Federal Government’s decade of gas initiative and aims to reduce Nigeria’s carbon footprint.

The PIA 2021 marks the end of petroleum industry reforms that began in 2008. It comes at a time when the global energy landscape is changing, with the United States transitioning from a petroleum importer to an exporter.

Emerging economies are actively seeking funding for oil and gas amidst the challenges of climate change. Proper implementation of the PIA 2021 is crucial for managing the future of oil and gas in Nigeria. However, various issues and challenges related to the PIA implementation process are arising. Criticism can help improve institutions rather than praise them superficially.

The first observation is the Upstream Petroleum Commission’s misunderstanding of its mandate from the former DPR. This needs to be addressed promptly. Secondly, the Authority appears to operate with the old PPRA mindset, making announcements not supported by PIA provisions. Efforts are underway to address this issue within the Petroleum Authority. It is concerning when regulators focus on generating revenue, which can lead to territorial protectionism and risk effective management of the industry.

NNPC Limited seems hesitant to relinquish its previous role and continues to influence petroleum policy advocacy for the central government, similar to its predecessor. Additionally, the Commission and the Authority are noticeably deferential to NNPC Limited, presenting a challenge for future management of oil and gas in Nigeria. The importance of adhering to role separation as outlined in the PIA 2021 is emphasized.

As frequently emphasized in various forums, the oil and gas sector cannot operate in isolation. Its macroeconomic impact on societal economic welfare becomes significant when any of the four macroeconomic markets—goods market, money market, labor market, and resources market—falls into disequilibrium. The consequences include social welfare losses, an escalating misery index characterized by high inflation, high unemployment, negative economic growth, and increased criminality. In petroleum-dependent economies like Nigeria, inadequate government interventions in the resources market, specifically the crude oil market, exacerbate the disequilibrium across these macroeconomic markets.

Additionally, the future of the oil and gas industry in Nigeria is influenced by changes in the domestic business structure and conduct. Historically, the sector was characterized by high barriers to entry and dominated by international oil companies (IOCs). However, recent developments such as the NOGIC Act 2010 and the substantial divestment of onshore and shallow water assets by IOCs have lowered these barriers. The fiscal framework under the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) appears less favorable for unlocking stranded onshore and shallow offshore reserves. Emerging indigenous operators, often in partnership with NNPC Limited, receive lower returns per unit of risked investment compared to those achieved by IOCs.

NNPC Limited’s frequent joint venturing raises concerns for managing Nigeria’s oil and gas future. While joint ventures spread upstream risk and help small firms, NNPC’s extensive stakes increase investment failure risks. The Board of Directors shouldn’t aim to maximize institutional capture as per PIA provisions.

Nigeria needs strategic planning to leverage its oil and gas resources for industrialization. Implementing the Petroleum Industry Act 2021 is crucial for this goal. Effective management of oil and gas is essential to mitigate unintended consequences from global decarbonization efforts aimed at reducing carbon emissions. The PIA’s policy, regulatory, and commercial institutions require a competent workforce to meet future expectations. Government should include knowledgeable academia on PIA boards for governance efficacy.

The evolving energy landscape presents opportunities rather than a trilemma. High-cost petroleum producers can benefit from cost reductions and technological advances, extending the oil market sustainably. Empirical evidence shows that displacing a dominant energy source doesn’t remove it from the supply mix.

Petroleum and Electricity Prices

The structure of the petroleum products market in Nigeria is characterized by oligopolistic competition at the retail level for Premium Motor Spirit (PMS) and diesel, with high concentration ratios among the top four and top eight firms. This oligopoly exists because the leading firms in the market significantly influence market behavior within this segment of the petroleum value chain. The retail diesel market for end-users also exhibits oligopolistic pricing dynamics due to interdependency among firms. In the PMS market, dominant firms such as NNPC Limited have historically influenced pricing dynamics, although this has begun to shift since the operationalization of Dangote Refinery.

NNPC Limited’s dominance in the PMS market is attributed to its near-monopoly power in the wholesale market, where it remains the sole importer of PMS despite some contention. However, the emergence of Dangote Refinery is gradually diminishing NNPC Limited’s market power. Statistically, there is a noticeable increase in the landing cost of PMS in Nigeria, which aligns with the rise in crude oil prices, albeit not proportionately. Additionally, the exchange rate fluctuations have significantly affected the price dynamics, with the value of the dollar in Naira tripling since May 2024.

Empirical evidence from literature suggests a direct correlation between crude oil prices and petroleum product prices. Contrary to the prevailing notion, empirical data indicates that subsidies exist in the PMS market in Nigeria. For instance, the average price of PMS in Ghana exceeds one dollar per liter, reflecting trends seen in Europe, the primary source of PMS for West Africa, including Nigeria. Globally, the price difference between diesel and petrol typically ranges from 10-20%, and Nigeria is beginning to align with this trend, potentially influenced by the throughput capacity of Dangote Refinery at 650,000 barrels per day.

The Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) of 2021 introduced three anchor institutions aimed at enhancing competitiveness in the petroleum market through improved structure, conduct, and performance. Unfortunately, outdated legislation such as the Petroleum Act of 1969, the Petroleum Pricing Regulatory Agency Act of 2003, and the NNPC Act of 1977 continue to overshadow modern regulatory frameworks. Consequently, market failures—such as illegal markets, PMS shortages, subsidies, long queues at retail stations, and social welfare losses—persist two years after the enactment of PIA 2021. Despite two decades of industry reform efforts, the sector appears to be stagnant, with entrenched transactional mindsets and prebendalistic tendencies preventing meaningful progress.

The Structure of the Power Market in Nigeria

The power market in Nigeria, like the petroleum market, consists of generation, transmission, and distribution segments. Each operates independently. The Electricity Act 2023 has significant potential to revitalize the power industry by decentralizing governance and encouraging state participation. While there are concerns about state governments creating their own power companies, it is notable that NERC is willing to transfer regulatory functions to state agencies. This marks a new era for Nigeria’s power sector and could lead to the decentralization of other sectors such as taxation, policing, education, and banking.

Power Generation Value Chain – The power generation segment of the electric power supply industry in Nigeria is characterized by an oligopolistic structure with a highly concentrated generating capacity among a few dominant firms. There is no empirical evidence of vertical integration across the power value chain in Nigeria since the dissolution of the National Electric Power Authority. The predominance of thermal gas power plants in Nigeria’s total power systems capacity raises concerns. Transitioning to renewable energy systems, such as hydroelectric power, appears desirable within a mixed energy strategic framework. Typically, gas power plants are effective in meeting peak demand.

Additionally, unlike the upstream value chain with an increasing marginal cost curve, the generating power value chain exhibits a decreasing marginal cost curve. Consequently, the pricing mechanism differs for investment optimization. The recent determination of wellhead gas prices for gas-to-power investments by the authority under the PIA 2021 deregulation expectations may not be advisable. The Act does not grant any governmental institutions in Nigeria the authority to set petroleum products or natural gas prices. Natural gas competes within its market, and fixing its price for a specific sectoral end user can compromise market allocation efficiency. High natural gas prices for power generation can increase electricity tariffs. When the natural gas price for power generation was raised, the electricity tariff for Band A customers increased from approximately 70 Naira per KWhr to 225 Naira per KWhr. Notably, there is no definitive guarantee that the twenty daily hours of electricity supply to Band A customers is enforceable.

Power Distribution Value Chain – This segment of the power value chain directly connects to end-users, and inadequate business performance in this sector impacts the entire value chain. The market structure in this segment is not a natural monopoly but a territorial monopoly. The territories assigned to each distribution company (Disco) are diverse in terms of market features—income, social structure, culture, access to the national grid, affordability, and adaptability. The inefficiency of this segment contributes to the limited access to affordable power in Nigeria. This is evident when comparing the 4000-5000 MW transmission capacity to the 10,000-15,000 MW generating capacity, indicating challenges in energy supply security. There is ongoing discussion about revisiting the sales agreements with Discos in Nigeria to reevaluate these agreements and revoke the licenses of underperforming Discos.

Power Pricing Mechanism – On April 1, 2024, Nigeria introduced a new tariff following the increase in natural gas prices. The 68 Naira per KWhr cap is far below the market clearing price and fair return for electricity, which isn’t sustainable for the power sector. Although differing opinions exist, it’s clear that this cap results in perpetual subsidies.

The new tariff system uses price discrimination, common in global power markets. Band A tariff’s accuracy is uncertain due to supply variability and model assumptions. As more data becomes available, the pricing model will be adjusted. Protecting consumer surplus due to affordability and metering issues is crucial. Reports indicate the ongoing price discrimination is based on daily supply hours, similar to mechanisms in the airline industry.

Source: The ValueChain