Skip links

PETROLEUM EXPLORATION, EXPLOITATION AND DEVELOPMENT IN NORTHERN NIGERIA: UNDERSTANDING THE FUNDAMENTALS AND IMPLICATIONS

PETROLEUM EXPLORATION, EXPLOITATION AND DEVELOPMENT IN NORTHERN NIGERIA: UNDERSTANDING THE FUNDAMENTALS AND IMPLICATIONS

By Omowumi O. Iledare, PhD, Professor Emeritus, LSU Energy Studies, USA, GNPC Petroleum Commerce Chair, UCC Institute for Oil and Gas Studies, GH, and Executive Director, Emmanuel Egbogah Foundation, Abuja, NG.

Petroleum resources and development have transformed the political governance of Nigeria literally shifting the decentralized governance in the 60s to overly centralized political structure with excessive power in the Centre.  To the extent that getting control of the enormous economic rent from petroleum extraction, regional sentiment has made national sentiment inconsequential.  Legitimately, therefore, it is not unusual to suggest or opine that oil discovery is more of a curse than a blessing to most petroleum provinces worldwide.

Abubakar Atiku Nuhu-Koko (AANK) of the Sokoto Energy Research Centre, Usmanu Danfodiyo University, Sokoto alluded to that fact in article posted on oil and gas perspective platform on November 23, 2022. He posed the proverbial question of whether the discovery of petroleum in a petroleum basin in Gombe and Bauchi States in Nigeria will be “a blessing or a curse” to the nation.  He premised this reflection on events of the past 66 years of oil exploration and exploitation in Nigeria and the contemporary global push for energy transition away from fossil energy resources and technologies to “Net-Zero Emissions” by 2050 or 2060.  Let me acknowledge AANK for granting PWI the permission to reproduce his opinion for a wider audience in the prestigious Oil and Gas Value Chain Magazine.

However, it is important to set the stage to facilitate good understanding of the oil curse or blessing presupposition within the context of finding petroleum in a Northern Nigeria Basin. Equally important in the discourse is a simple proverbial saying, that not everything that glitter is gold. Thus, what needs to be kept in mind is that commercial discovery of petroleum resources is dictated by current economic conditions and existing technology to produce such a discovery at a defined date in the future. The size of such a discovery is classified based on the likelihood of recoverability dictated majorly by stochastic variables—geology, engineering, economics, finance, and politics among others. Anything less than 90% chance of development and ultimate recoverability is classified as unproved reserves.

To a large extent, I have not seen in the public domain consistent estimated size of discovery made in the Gongola Basin in Gombe and Bauchi states. Neither has the estimated likelihood of development of the discovery in a known date forward established in the public domain. The data on the discovery of a reservoir must be made available to the Commission and a commission staff can choose to be present to observe well testing. To date, the Commission has been silent and the status of proved reserves in Nigeria has not inched up. Ideally, a well cannot be classified to have made a commercial discovery without a certification by the Commission. Thus, a discovery of the size peddling in the media cannot be announced by the Commission without some worldwide crude price volatile reaction. Perhaps, time will tell and well that time comes, AANK offers perspective on what ought to be done to avoid unintended consequences of oil discovery in commercial quantity in a petroleum basin.

Is the Discovery of Petroleum in Northern Nigeria a Curse or Blessing?

By Abubakar Atiku Nuhu-Koko (AANK), Sokoto Energy Research Centre, Usmanu Danfodiyo University, Sokoto

The vast literature on oil – a Blessing or a Curse have deep roots in trying to explain why on the one hand, some nations blessed with God-given fossil energy (oil and gas) resources did well economically and socially. For example, Saudi Arabia is one of the richest nations on the planet, thanks to its large oil reserves. While on the other hand, some oil, gas, and other natural resources rich countries performed below expectations compared even with those with almost zero presence of such bounties (Japan and Singapore for example). For instance, from Iraq to Iran, Venezuela to Nigeria, few oil-rich countries have prospered from the discovery of crude oil and gas. Economists call it the “curse of oil”.

Oil discovery if not handled properly destroys a nation’s traditional diversified export economy and replaced by a mono cultural export (enclave) economy with all the consequential negative impacts on the macro economy, especially the exchange rate mechanism. Thus, there are vast empirical literature out there which try to make comparative analyses and explanations among the nations that are blessed with oil and gas (and other natural resources – gold, diamond, copper and timber etc.) resources which have become very successful in the management of the huge financial in-flows from exploiting, developing and exporting them in the global oil and gas markets and those that are similarly blessed with oil and gas resources but have not successfully managed the revenue in-flows arising from exploiting, developing and exporting the oil and gas in the international markets.

Therefore, these two paradoxical situations gave rise to the notion of “a blessing or a curse” types of scenarios. Unfortunately, Nigeria falls into this latter category of nations abundantly blessed with God-given oil and gas resources but seems afflicted with the “curse of oil” and gas due to the squandering of the greatest opportunities brought about by the discovery of the oil and gas resources in the history of the country. However, as earlier pointed out above, the discovery of oil, gas and other natural resources (gold, diamond, copper, timber etc.) have been blessings for those countries who used these resources right and wisely too. For example, as earlier mentioned above, it is not only the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, but include nations such as Norway, USA, Canada, The Netherlands, Russia and some of the very rich Gulf oil and gas producing countries are considered lucky in successfully managing the easy incomes and wealth accruing from the depleting oil and gas resources.

On the other hand, it can be recalled what Saddam Hussein did to oil revenues in Iraq and other counties like Nigeria, Angola and Venezuela that have misused their oil and gas revenues and impoverished their economies and peoples; making them poorer than they were before discovering oil and gas resources! Nigeria has a record history of 66 years of discovery of oil and gas in its southern onshore coastal mangrove delta region of its land territory in 1956 at Oloibiri in the present day Bayelsa State and not long ago, in its deep water offshore international maritime boundary. Thus, it took another 60 years for crude oil and gas to be struck in commercial quantities in the Northeastern region of Nigeria. The modern oil industry can trace its origins to Baku in 1837, where the first commercial oil refinery was established to distil oil into paraffin (used as lamp and heating oil). This was followed by the first modern oil well in 1846, which reached a depth of 21 metres. At this time, a single oil field in Baku accounted for over 90% of the world’s oil production, mostly going to Persia (now Iran). Commercial oil wells soon followed in Bobrka, Poland (1854), Bucharest, Romania (1857), Ontario, Canada (1858) and Pennsylvania, USA (1859), sparking a ‘black gold’ rush in several of these regions. Pennsylvania was the clear winner and within a couple of years was producing almost half of the world’s oil. Prices rose quickly – from roughly $0.49 a barrel in 1861 to $6.59 a barrel in 1865.That is now history!!!

Oil is now “the source of energy that’s more than coal, and more than twice as much as nuclear, hydroelectric and renewable energy sources combined.” Furthermore, “Oil and gas together provide a quarter of the world’s electricity, and the raw material for more than 6,000 different products: including plastics. Edwin Drake who discovered crude oil in Pennsylvania, USA, may have questioned who would buy gasoline after obtaining his paraffin, but the internal combustion engine was about to give him an answer. From cars to trucks, cargo ships to jet planes, oil-derived fuel still moves us and stuff – around.” But is this about to change? Renewable electricity (Solar and Wind, and Green Hydrogen) and other new non-polluting (fusion energy) and low-carbon emission sources of energy and technologies are about to replace liquid and gas fuels that power vehicles, airplanes and ships; thereby replacing internal combustion engines that drives the world’s transportation systems. Similarly, the major industrial economies of the world are transiting from fossil fuel powered economies; fossil fuels based-electricity generation and industrial manufacturing processes to clean renewable energy sources and technologies.

The energy transition from dirty fossil energy sources and technologies became necessary for the need to address the global climate change phenomenon brought about by the greenhouse gases (methane and carbon in particular) emissions from the utilization of fossil energy resources and technologies beginning from 1864!!! Therefore, recent discovery of oil and gas in commercially exploitable quantities in the northeastern corridor of the country should be analyzed from at least two major perspectives or paradox. Firstly, it comes at the time of the global transition from fossil energy sources and technologies to cleaner non-fossil energy sources and technologies.  Secondly, it brings about a fresh breath for not only substantially adding to Nigeria’s proven national reserves of oil and gas (additional over one billion barrels of crude oil and over 500 billion standard cubic feet of gas) in the Southern onshore oil and gas rich region and the offshore territorial deep waters of the country, but also, joy and blessings to the good peoples in the northern region of the country (i.e. no longer blackmailed and seen as a “Parasite region”) in particular and the rest of the country in general.

Hence, it is against the above backdrop that the question that begets the minds of many concerned Nigerians like my humble self has always been, are the past mistakes of oil and gas discovery in Nigeria going to be repeated once again in the management of this recent discovery of oil and gas reserves at Kolmani oil and gas bearing geological formation? In other word, is the discovery going to be a blessing or the proverbial curse associated with what Juan Perez Alfonso referred to as the “Devil’s Excrement” (crude oil)? “We are drowning in the devil’s excrement.” (Alfonso, 1975).

But, finally, for the new discovery of oil and gas reserves to be a blessing and avoid the associated curse, it is my prayer and conclusion that Nigeria should not continue to repeat the mistakes of the past (there are still many of them indeed). President Muhammadu Buhari’s speech delivered at the official flag-off ceremony of the validation phase of the first integrated Oil Development project in the area on Tuesday, November 22, 2022, at the Kolmani River OPLs 809 and 810 exploration sites (a boundary community between Bauchi and Gombe States), equally cautioned about the repeat of the mistakes of the development of the oil and gas reservoirs in the geological formations in the Niger Delta area. The mistakes go beyond environmental despoliation, host community poverty and underdevelopment, oil theft, vandalism of oil and gas infrastructures and militancy by the frustrated and unemployed poverty-stricken youths. They include monumental public policy failures that breed high level of corruption and mismanagement across all the layers of management of the sector.

Concluding Remarks

Searching for oil and gas in the Northern basins in Nigeria is not new.  Neither is the recent announcement of a discovery in the North new either.  The only thing new is the PIA Era.  NNPC Limited is now a liability corporation.  The modus operandi of petroleum operations in Nigeria is no longer the Petroleum Act of 1969 but the Petroleum Act of 2021.  One of the fundamental objectives of the latter is transparency and accountability with a unique deliverable being the separation of roles among the three anchor institutions in the PIA 2021.

The concern emanating from the petroleum commercialization pronouncement by NNPC Limited, or the Minister is the absence of the Petroleum Commission in the commercialization discussions. This negates the transparency and accountability agenda in the PIA. Who approved the field development plan and on what basis? I am also particularly disappointed when professionals become overly sentimental on things that are of national value and often so willing to keep mute and/or compromise normality for abnormality because of sentiments.

Perhaps, one good thing that can come out of a commercial discovery of petroleum in any of the northern basins is the enablement of economic restructuring of Nigeria, which is needed so badly to make the Center less attractive to political gladiators. The future is more important than now for the massive unskilled population, which petroleum by itself cannot unshackle from economic poverty without transformation leadership mindset. Time will tell as our professor of what ought to be waits patiently on time.

SOURCE: The ValueChain