Skip links

PIB 2020: A Perspective on The Host and Impacted Community Development Provision

In light of the potential passage of the PIB by the National Assembly, a public hearing was held on the provisions of the Petroleum Industry Bill (PIB) 2020. Following this hearing, some concerns were raised by the host communities on the provisions for host community development in the bill. The bill’s objective for the host communities is tailored, to provide direct social and economic benefits from petroleum operations to host communities, foster sustainable prosperity within host communities, create a framework to support the development of host communities and enhance harmonious co-existence between the oil companies and host communities. While these objectives are laudable, representatives of the host communities have argued that the proposed compensation to the communities is a mockery and undermines the people.

It is based on this background, that we examine the proposed compensation to the host communities in the PIB 2020 against the current demand by the host communities. This brief aims to highlight the potential impacts of both compensation options on the host communities. In the PIB 2020, the provision for the host community development component mandates the settlor to incorporate a trust for the benefit of the host communities for which the settlor is responsible (“host community development trust”). Wherein, a ‘settlor” is a holder of an interest in a petroleum prospecting license or petroleum mining lease or a holder of an interest in a license for midstream petroleum operations, whose area of operations is located in or appurtenant to any community or communities.

The host community development trust is to be funded by the settlor’s annual contribution of an amount equal to 2.5% of its actual operating expenditures in the immediately preceding calendar year in respect of all petroleum operations affecting the host communities for which the applicable development trust was established. The operating expenditures are described as expenditures that occur periodically and are necessary for the day-to-day operations of the field. These expenditures are broken down to include feedstocks, utilities, maintenance, administrative and general overhead, production costs, evacuation costs and insurance. Given the definition of an operating expenditure, the compensation from this arrangement guarantees a constant revenue inflow to the host community for the duration of the settlor’s operations. The host community representatives have however argued against this proposed compensation and insisted on a 10% equity stressing that anything short of that will be counterproductive. This recent demand thus, raises the question on what a 10% equity share means for the host communities?

Equity according to the Natural Resource Governance Institute Parliamentary Briefing 2015, is broken into three types; paid, carried and free. With the paid equity, the state/host community pays a market rate for its shares and may be obligated to pay cash calls for project development expenses, as a private partner would. The carried equity on the other hand is equity received based on preferential terms. In this case, the oil and gas operator finance the operation upfront and the host community pays for its equity via foregone dividends, which absolves the state of the responsibility to pay cash out of pocket but delays financial returns to equity. With the free equity, the government pays nothing for its equity, but it does not come without costs to the state/host community. Free equity can deter investment and where instituted, typically obligates states to make trade-offs elsewhere in the fiscal package, in the form of lower taxes or royalties. There are however financial benefits for equity holders in form of share of oil and dividend payment.

The direct financial benefits of the paid and carried equity entitles the host community to a share of the resource produced, which the community might sell itself, or which might be monetized via cash payments from the private oil company to the community. With the free equity however the host community is entitled to some form of dividend payment if a project is profitable, much like payments to shareholders in a publicly traded company. With this sort of arrangement, the private companies often control the accounting procedures that lead to the declaration of dividends. As a result, dividends are paid only after a project has recovered all upfront costs, meaning that they are often awarded years after the project’s start, which might lead to disappointing dividends for the host communities.

Based on our understanding of the different equity types, it is essential that the following questions are posed for clarity:

  • If the host community is given a 10% equity stake, is it paid, carried or free?
  • If the host community equity stake is free? Are the communities receptive to not receiving dividends when the operating companies declare losses?
  • What are the host communities willing to give up for a free 10% equity share?
  • Will potential dividends be sufficient for effective host community development?
  • Will the equity stake for the host community be derived from the government’s or operator’s equity participation?
  • Does the host community equity participation effectively foster sustainable prosperity within the host communities?

From these questions, it is obvious that the subject of host community equity participation is not simple as many would have thought. Thus, in advocating for an equity participation by the host communities, a proper definition of the type of equity is required to enhance public understanding and consensus-building. The host communities further need to determine what they are willing to trade off for an equity stake.  In answering these questions, the best compensation option for the host communities will probably become evident or not.